Return to Higgins Home Page

Franz Schubert: Ethics and Aesthetics

In the film Conspiracy (2001) Kenneth Branagh plays Reinhard Heydrich and Stanley Tucci plays Adolf Eichmann in a reconstruction of the Wannsee Conference of January 1942. A dozen middle-aged men, some in uniform, some in suits, sit around a table discussing a “storage problem”. In between they eat from a lavish buffet, drink fine wines, and smoke cigars, which makes one of them sick. By the end of the discussion they have agreed the “final solution of the Jewish problem”, mass murder.

As the meeting closes and the participants are dispersing, Heydrich picks up a gramophone record from a pile. “Ah, Schubert, Quintet in C major. The adagio will tear your heart out.”

A few minutes later all the guests have gone, leaving only Adolf Eichmann and the staff. Eichmann picks up the record and puts it on the turntable. As the music starts he asks the head waiter, “Does it tear your heart out?”

“Beautiful, sir” comes the reply.

Eichmann shakes his head. “I have never understood the passion for Schubert’s sentimental Viennese shit,” he says. The music plays on as he walks away and we see before the end credits short accounts of what happened to each of the participants at the conclusion of the War.

I don’t suppose there is firm evidence about whether Heydrich loved Schubert’s music or Eichmann hated it. Both attitudes are quite plausible. What is interesting is what the scriptwriter, Loring Mandel, is asking us to think about music and conscience, or music and spirituality. Has one any right to be moved by profound art at the same time as perpetrating a great evil? Do we like Heydrich any better because he loves Schubert? Or worse? Does Eichmann’s attitude change our own attitude to him?

Or, to change one’s viewpoint, should an artist communicating something profound and beautiful make it harder for us to pursue an evil way of life? If Heydrich loves the Quintet and murders Jews, has Schubert failed? Or are ethics and aesthetics completely unconnected? I suppose that is what the scriptwriter is really telling us.

John Higgins, Shaftesbury, 2010
Also see my pieces on Hans Gál: Music Behind Barbed Wire, the Schubertiades at Rhosygilwen, and My Kind of Music.
Visit the Schubert Institute UK.