Return to Higgins Home Page

My Kind of Music

In 1958 when I was in the Army in Germany, aged nineteen, I won a script-writing competition for which the prize was to go to Cologne and present a one-hour radio programme on the British Forces Broadcasting Service called My Kind of Music, introducing about ten records. The producer who looked after me was Gerald Sinstadt, who later became quite well known as a football pundit. I did not keep the script and have forgotten exactly what I included, though the conditions of the competition excluded anything very highbrow. All I remember for sure is that I included the Gold and Silver Waltz of Lehar and Julie London singing Cry me a River, neither of which would figure in my current Desert Island Discs selection. My tastes have broadened and changed, so this is my later-life update of that experience.

We had a wind-up gramophone at home in the early 1950s with 78 rpm records, of which the only one I remember well is Mendelssohn's Italian Symphony. My first classical concert was in Wells Cathedral, the Hallé Orchestra under Sir John Barbirolli, a trip organised by the school (Clifton College) when I was about 14. Barbirolli conducted vigorously, tossing his hair, and the boy beside me commented that it looked as if it could do with a wash. The Enigma Variations was the main item. I had some interest in but little talent for music. I had a few lessons on the clarinet which I was glad to give up. I was in the school choral society for my last two years, but that was almost compulsory. We performed Bach’s B minor Mass and Verdi's Requiem in Bristol Cathedral in a large combined schools effort. There was almost no exposure to anything you could call pop. When my cousin Clare enthused about something called Rock 'n' Roll and a singer called Elvis Presley, I probably smiled in a superior way.

My first exposure to Schubert was the German master, Mr Clarke, playing in class a record of Erlkönig sung by Fischer-Dieskau. I think I was more won over by the words than the music at that point, but I did acquire a record player and a recording on LP of Fischer-Dieskau singing Winterreise in my last term, and played it often, so often that I could sing the whole cycle from memory after a fashion many years later. Since then Schubert has become a hobby for me, going to concerts organised by the Schubert Society and supporting them. I think I own every piece of his music that has been commercially recorded.[1]

I think school made me into a consumer of music, though not a maker. There must have been quite a lot of recorded music around, and it left me with a recognition knowledge of much of the standard orchestral repertoire. There was also a school trip to Paris which included a visit to the Opéra Comique for a performance of Carmen. Carmen herself was sung by Solange Michel who was held to be the best interpreter of the role at the time, and I later acquired a CD of her performance. Perversely I always liked the music sung by the poor abandoned Micaela much better than Carmen’s more famous numbers, especially Micaela’s Act III solo when she is wandering in the mountains looking for Don José, which always makes me cry. Later came the film Carmen Jones, in which Oscar Hammerstein created miraculously fitting lyrics for the music, turning “Je dis que rien ne m’épouvante” into “My Joe, he was always my Joe”, by no means a word-for-word translation.[2]

My memories of basic training in the Army are coloured with memories of a juke box in the NAAFI at Catterick Camp endlessly playing Paul Anka’s Diana, surely one of the most annoying and depressing one-note melodies ever. (“I’m so young and you’re so old. This my darling I’ve been told. I don’t care just what they say, cos forever I will pray, You and I will be as free As the birds up in the tree, Oh, please, stay with me, Diana.”) In the Army I was posted to Herford in Westphalia as a clerk in the Royal Signals, having dropped out of an officer training course which I hated. Herford had the distinction of being the only town in north Germany which had an intact concert hall in 1945. As a result it got much more than its fair share of music. It had a symphony orchestra which gave eight concerts a year on a fairly cheap subscription basis, along with visiting soloists, among whom I remember the pianist Friedrich Wuehrer looking, probably deliberately, like the pictures of Franz Liszt in old age.

My immediate army boss was Corporal Zatz, who introduced me to a group of soldiers who would go once a week to the house of a little old lady (she really did look, sound and behave like that cliché) called Frau Hebrock. She was the widow of a Wehrmacht pastor, and saw it as her mission to bring young Germans and Brits together. We would sit in her lounge, sipping milkless tea, talking in careful English or strained German to a gathering of young Germans, mostly female. And there was a piano and plenty of music.

The chief music maker was David Greensmith, who played Schubert sonatas, having brought with him a book of them, or accompanied our singing. He was a Cambridge organ scholar, and would go on to be headmaster of Kidbrooke School. He became a close friend and was even best man at our wedding, though we lost touch later, the result of our very peripatetic career with many changes of address. It was David who cemented my love of Schubert, especially the piano music. Others of the group that I remember were Robert Field, a very good singer, and Carl Leonard whose profession was organ builder, so he too was musical. One thing we did was to make a recording of Stainer’s Crucifixion, arranged for the available four male voices and piano, which was pressed into an LP as a gift for our German hosts. Considering the date, it was surprisingly cheap to record it and run off ten copies. I have lost my own copy, but I remember that the sound quality was dreadfully fuzzy. The music itself is by no means a favourite, though there is one chorus, God so loved the world, that is attractive in a romantic way. Another work I was introduced to then was Finzi’s Dies Natalis, which I later acquired on an LP sung by Wilfred Brown, for years the only available record, though it is now much better known and I have since then found and bought four other recordings.[3]

We also sang Flanders and Swann songs, the Hippoppotamus song of course and Madeira M’Dear, which became my party pieces later. My favourite of the Flanders and Swann songs is one that came out much later, The Armadillo, with its splendid line: “Never tell a man the truth about the one that he adores.”[4]

Another venture from my army days was for the group to hire a van, take a week’s leave together (not sure how we managed to dovetail all the arrangements) and drive to Bayreuth with tickets for Tristan und Isolde, with Birgit Nilsson singing. That one did not work for me. I still don’t get Wagner.

Oxford did almost nothing for my musical education. I had some LPs which I played sometimes as soothing background to study. There is one piece I remember playing late at night, a Boccherini guitar quintet. It is not a great work or at all well known, but I can play it now to bring back the strain of trying to think of something interesting to say about Paradise Lost. I must have had more than a dozen records with me, but they were all stolen from the digs I went into in my second year. I had a good friend called Clive Jenkins who played the piano purely to entertain himself and was working his way through all the Beethoven sonatas. For my 21st birthday he gave me a record of Dvorak’s Cello Concerto; what was remarkable was that he said he had gone to the record shop and had insisted on playing through three different recordings there before selecting one (Rostropovich).

Leeds meant a new and much more exciting subject to study, and meeting and marrying Muriel. She extended my musical horizon with Mozart’s Die Entführung and Lortzing’s Zar und Zimmermann. Later I dug further into Lortzing and collected all of his operas that have been recorded, which means only about a quarter of them. He sounds like a jolly chap who enjoyed the good things of life but had to work hard to pay for them. Like Victor Canning he might have been more famous if he had written rather less. He is virtually unknown outside Germany, and no longer very well known there.[5]

Going out to our first posting, Chiang Mai in Thailand, we took a Philips open-reel tape recorder and about half a dozen tapes. Played at the slow speed of 1⅞"/sec, one could fit about four hours music onto a tape at just acceptable quality. One tape was a recording of our wedding service, and one was a day’s worth of BBC speech broadcasts, news bulletins, weather forecasts, comedy shows, talks, and a small religious slot called “Five to Ten; a story, a hymn and a prayer.” I was rather proud of being able to take all this authentic language into classes, but in the end I did not make as much use of it as I should have. The rest of the tapes were off-air recording of classical music, quite a lot of Mozart and Haydn, with some Beethoven, Brahms, Schubert and Dvorak, which taught me that it is easy to get tired of sixteen hours of music if that is all you have over two years.

My main memory of music in Norway (1966-8) was of visits to the Oslo opera. The minor roles and the chorus parts were usually sung in Norwegian, but often the principals were imported stars who would sing in the original language. I particularly remember productions of Cosi fan tutte and Tosca in which this happened. Later in Turkey we found the same thing happening, so it is probably quite common.[6]

One other highlight was a song recital by Janet Baker, at that point becoming very well known. Our university colleague Jack Windsor Lewis was writing pronunciation exercises and wrote one celebrating that evening, from which I remember the line “I nearly had apoplexy!”

We were also discovering the songs of Tom Lehrer, and he once came to an evening at which some of his songs were being performed in a Norwegian translation. I still have a programme from that evening which he signed. The best of Tom Lehrer has some outrageous rhymes. My favourite is from The Vatican Rag:[7]

Say whatever lines you want if
You have cleared them with the Pontiff.
Everybody say his own
Kyrie eleison
Doing the Vatican Rag.

In Egypt I was roped in to sing the role of Bosun in HMS Pinafore. Our friends the Hay-Campbells are G and S enthusiasts, and I got to know all the operas well. My favourite is Princess Ida, which is less often performed that Mikado or Gondoliers since it has the rather unfashionable subject of education for women (and what a waste it is). But the music is the best of all. When it comes to the discussion of Gilbert versus Sullivan, I have always wanted to hear a G and S opera sung in a language that I don’t know, and I eventually found one in the shape of The Mikado sung in Japanese. But perhaps one of the best blends of the right words with the right music is the Act I finale from Ruddigore.[8]

Latterly I have swung much more to the romantic composers, unlike Muriel who has stayed determinedly loyal to the baroque era. There are many of them, in addition to the familiar names of Mendelssohn, Schumann, Chopin, Brahms and Dvorak. Hearing something on the car radio I am often astonished that some attractive piece is by a composer I have never heard of, Paisiello, Eberl, etc. Two in particular have appealed, Johann Nepomuck Hummel and Louis Spohr. I learned that these are sometimes called the “sunshine composers”, as their music is rarely gloomy or very profound, and some of the best performers avoid them as they are afraid they will be accused of not taking on the difficulties of Beethoven and Bach.[9]

But I always come back to Schubert. He died just before his thirty-second birthday, even younger than our daughter Ana. It is extraordinary that we still have so much of his music, and tells us something of the way he was valued by his friends. Perhaps my favourite piece is one that is very little known, the slow movement of one of his unfinished symphonies, not the famous Eighth but the Seventh, orchestrated by Brian Newbould, a professor of music and Schubert expert two of whose courses I have attended. This would be my single selection, but of course, as we learned in Chiang Mai, taking just eight or ten records to a desert island would be dangerous; one might end up hating them.[10]

(Even worse would be one book. One of these days I’ll try to assemble a Desert Island library. It might include some Shakespeare, but I would certainly trade in the Bible for something with a bit more truth and interest.)

The Desert Island discs

[1] Schubert: “Der Lindenbaum” from Winterreise. Fischer-Dieskau and Gerald Moore

[2] Bizet/Hammerstein: Carmen Jones, “My Joe”. Olga James

[3] Gerald Finzi: Dies Natalis, last movement. Wilfred Brown and ECO cond. Christopher Finzi

[4] Flanders and Swann: “The Armadillo”

[5] Lortzing: Zar und Zimmermann, Clog dance. Munich Radio Orchestra

[6] Mozart, Cosi fan Tutte, “Per pieta”

[7] Tom Lehrer: “The Vatican Rag”

[8] Gilbert and Sullivan: Ruddigore, “Oh happy the lily”. Pro Arte Orch. cond. Malcolm Sargent

[9] Hummel: Piano Concerto in B minor, first movement. Stephen Hough and the ECO

[10] Schubert: Symphony 7, slow movement. Academy of St Martin’s, cond. Neville Marriner

John Higgins, Shaftesbury, December 2019
Also see my pieces on Hans Gál: Music Behind Barbed Wire, the Schubertiades at Rhosygilwen, and Franz Schubert: Ethics and Aesthetics.
Visit the Schubert Institute UK.